Skip to main content

Blog

Telematics and car insurance at renewal

ALAndrew Little on November 17, 2026
3 min read

One Holy Grail for some Motor Insurers is telematics data at time of quote. Driver insight. Risk insight. Quote for new or renewal business.

A number of ideas have been thrashed around. But first some more context. A recent FCA survey characterised consumer renewal experiences in motor thus:

  • 80% of consumers experience an increase in renewal price
  • Average price increase +27%
  • 74% of consumers then take action: shop around, change provider or negotiate
  • Consumer dissatisfaction is exacerbated by taking that action, why weren’t they offered that price in the first place?
  • 40% of consumers feel car insurance is not good value even after securing a deal

Three aspects in all that for me: transparency; fairness; and stemming from those two, value.

Transparency

Why has my premium increased by xx%? As a glorious market of one, my renewal quote was +400%, without having made a claim. Can macro reasons (loss ratio tanked due to ……) comfort the individual? I sincerely doubt it.

Fairness

Defined as: ‘the quality of treating people equally or in a way that is right or reasonable’ (Cambridge English Dictionary). Right or reasonable according to whom? Well, as a marketer, it must be in the eyes of the consumer, surely? Typically, sense of fairness has been skewed by pricing. However, a recent Oxford University study cites targeting, relevance, control (can I, the individual, influence that targeting, for example) and intentionality. The last is especially interesting for the big insurer, as big brands are perceived as having the ad budgets to discriminate in their targeting; smaller less so. In other words, larger companies have an option to behave differently.

Value

Consumer value perception is the subjective evaluation of a product or service’s worth, balancing perceived benefits against perceived costs. Benefits include functional and emotional; costs means money, time, and effort. Considering a consumer journey from first search (new or renewal) through shop around through completion of forms to some sort of evaluation of not just price but experience is a lot. And clearly that sense of value can be disrupted in the event of a claim.

How can telematics help?

Well……..I have corresponded previously on personalisation, and the US success in having consumers exchange Usage Based Insurance (UBI) data for premium or other benefits. I have not yet seen data on the impact of that new relationship on renewals, for example. However, to consider telematics’ contribution by the parameters above, how about the below:

Redtail resource image

Keeping it simple. I am sure there is more opportunity. Available at point of quote, IF that telematics data becomes transferrable (as NCD) – utopian vision but hey, why not! My punchline is of course that OF COURSE Telematics can deliver value for the insurer here, through broad adoption of the programmes associated with the benefits above. Just take that step. Call me!

Andrew Little

Head of Marketing & Sales

+44 (0)7964 900232

sales@redtailtelematics.com

www.redtailtelematics.com

Share this article